Showing posts with label Moral Damages. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Moral Damages. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 17, 2010

Austria: new Supreme Court decision on loss of holiday enjoyment


A couple booked a package holiday arrangement for their honeymoon in Egypt at EUR 1.448. Back home they complained about improper performance and assigned their claims to a consumer protection association (Verein für Konsumenteninformation - VKI) which sued for a price reduction of EUR 1.320,90 and compensation for loss of holiday enjoyment of EUR 560 (deducting a refund of EUR 141 by the tour operator).

First instance court (Bezirksgericht für Handelssachen Wien) granted additional EUR 150,60 comprising of a price reduction of 5 % for a defect air condition, 5 % for construction noise and another 10 % for an insufficient beach space (contrary to promises in the brochure) but dismissed the claim for compensation for loss of holiday enjoyment.

Appelate court (Commercial Court Vienna - Handelsgericht Wien) doubled the price reduction by granting additional 5 % for bad water quality of the pool, 5 % for ponding the room when flowers were watered and another 10 % for noise during the night. However, appelate court upheld dismissal of the claim for compensation for loss of holiday enjoyment: the shortcomings had not exceeded the threshold of relevance.

Upon further appeal by the plaintiff, Supreme Court in judgement 2 Ob 45/10x of June 17, 2010 emphasized the different legal nature and purpose of price reduction on the one hand and compensation for loss of holiday enjoyment on the other. Following a previous decision, Supreme Court decided in favour of a rather low threshold of relevance and granted the claim for compensation for loss of holiday enjoyment. However, Supreme Court disagreed with the view that the threshold of relevance with regard to loss of holiday enjoyment should be equated with any shortcoming more than negligible under warranty law.

The total grant thus amounted to EUR 1.002,20. Supreme Court noted that the price reduction granted by the appelate court (which was not subject of his decison) was "very generous" in favour of the claimants.

Note:
1) Even given this generous grant, the consumer protection association only succeeded with roughly 58 % of the claim - which proves a tendency of the assocoation to sue for excessive amounts.
2) The fact that it was a honeymoon trip was not decisive.

Full text of judgement 2 Ob 45/10x of June 17, 2010 available in German here>>.

Thursday, May 27, 2010

Germany: who can claim compensation for loss of holiday enjoyment?

Plaintiff had booked a Danube cruise arrangement with defendant for himself and his wife. As defendant cancelled the cruise, plaintiff claimed for compensation for loss of holiday enjoyment. Defendant payed a compensation half of the packacke price for one person to plaintiff but refused to pay any compensation in regard to plaintiff's wife, arguing plaintiff had had no authorisation by his wife when asserting the claim. A later assignation of the claim had missed the one month deadline. Plaintiff therefore filed a law suit.

Both, court of first instance (AG Frankfurt am Main) and appelate court (LG Frankfurt am Main) granted the claim: even though until to the assignation only plaintiff's wife herself had been entitled to the claim, the assignation constituted a retroactive authorization of the plaintiff.

In judgement Xa ZR 124/09 of May 26, 2010, German Supreme Court upheld these decisions. Though the court tended to the view that plaintiff as contract partner of defendant was entitled to file an individual suit this issue didn't have to be definitely clarified as the assignation had constituted a retroactive authorization, anyway.

Source: BGH press release 109/2010 of May 26, 2010

Monday, May 10, 2010

European Court of Justice: liability limit of Montreal Convention includes both material and non-material damage

The Montral Convention provides that the liability of a carrier in the case of destruction, loss, damage or delay of baggage is limited to the sum of 1000 Special Drawing Rights (SDR) for each passenger (a sum equivalent to approximately €1134.71)3, unless a passenger has made, at the time when the checked baggage was handed over to the carrier, a special declaration of interest in delivery at destination and has paid a supplementary sum if the case so requires. In that case, as a rule a carrier is liable to pay a sum not exceeding the declared sum.

On 14 April 2008, Mr Walz brought an action against the airline Clickair claiming damages from it for the loss of checked baggage in the context of a flight from Barcelona (Spain) to Oporto (Portugal) operated by that company. In that action, Mr Walz claimed total damages of €3200: €2700 for the value of the lost baggage and €500 for non-material damage resulting from that loss. The Juzgado de lo Mercantil nº 4 de Barcelona (Commercial Court No 4, Barcelona, Spain), before which the proceedings were brought, asks whether the limit of air carriers’ liability set by the Montreal Convention in the case of loss of baggage includes both material and non-material damage or whether, on the contrary, material damage is subject to the limit of 1000 SDR, while, on the other hand, non-material damage is subject to a further limit of the same amount, so that the total combined limit for material and non-material damage is 2000 SDR.

European Court of Justice on May 6, 2010 ruled that for the purposes of determining the limit of an air carrier’s liability for the damage resulting, inter alia, from the loss of baggage, the term ‘damage’ in the Montreal Convention must be interpreted as including both material and non-material damage.

Source: ECJ press release 43/10
Full text of judgement Walz v Clickair C-63/09 available here>>.

Friday, March 12, 2010

Spain: Court ruling on missed connecting flight and lost baggage

Plaintiffs purchased flight tickets from Barcelona to Mexico City via London. The initial flight to London took off 30 minutes delayed. As a consequence, plaintiffs missed their connecting flight to Mexico City. The airline placed the plaintiffs on an alternative flight, which arrived in Mexico City more than nine hours later than originally planned. On arrival a piece of plaintiffs' luggage was lost.

First instance court granted €1,200 in damages for the delay under EU Regulation 261/2004 and €1,150 in compensation for the lost suitcase, pursuant to Article 22 of the Montreal Convention.

On appeal of both parties, Barcelona Provincial Court ruled that
  • the original flight could not be divided into two separate flights (ie, Barcelona to London and London to Mexico City), but must be considered as a whole (ie, Barcelona to Mexico City) compensate plaintiffs in the amount determined at first instance and
  • compensation for material and non material damages together may not exceed the limit established in the Montreal Convention and again confirmed the amount of compensation determined at first instance.
Source (Copyright): ILO Newsletter; find article by Miguel Gordillo here>>.

Summary posted with kind permission of author and pursuant to ILO copy right information.

Tuesday, February 16, 2010

ECJ Advocate General Mazák: liability limits of Montreal Convention cover both, non-material and material damage

Mr. Walz' checked suitcase was lost on 4 June 2007 during a flight from Barcelona to Porto operated by Clickair. Mr Walz claimed damages of EUR 3 200: EUR 2 700 for the value of the lost baggage and EUR 500 for non-material damage resulting from that loss. Clickair challenged the amount of the damages claimed because it exceeded the limit for liability for lost baggage laid down by Article 22.2 Montreal Convention.

The referring court (Juzgado de lo Mercantil No 4 de Barcelona) observed that the Montreal Convention did not draw any distinction according to the type of damage to which the carrier’s liability relates, and took the view that the limitation on the carrier’s liability should cover both non-material and material damage. However, it indicated that a number of interpretations of Article 22.2 of the Montreal Convention were possible.

In his opinion delivered on 26 January 2010, Advocate General Mazák proposed that the Court should answer the question referred as follows:

  • Article 22(2) of the Convention for the Unification of Certain Rules for International Carriage, signed in Montreal on 28 May 1999, must be interpreted as meaning that, in the transport of baggage, the liability of the carrier in the case of destruction, loss, damage or delay is limited to 1 000 Special Drawing Rights per passenger in total, whatever the type of damage and the method of providing compensation.
Case C-63/09 - Axel Walz v. Clickair S.A; full text of opinion available here>>.

Monday, November 16, 2009

Austria: Supreme Court decides on information duties with regard to hurricane hazard

Plaintiff and his fiancé wanted to go on vacation in late October 2005 and asked their travel agency for a destination of fair weather. The agency inter alia offered Yucatan/Mexico which they chose and booked a package tour for Oct. 16 to 30. When they left for Yucatan on Oct. 16, a tropical depression had developed in the Carribean which on Oct. 18 turned into hurricane Wilma. Plaintiff and his fiancé enjoyed their vacations until Oct. 19 when heavy wind came up and the hotel staff began to nail up windows. From Oct. 20 they were asked not to leave their room. The storm calmed down on Oct. 23 and left much of the neighbourhood of the hotel and most of the surrounding infrastrcuture destroyed. Plaintiff and his fiancé were flown home on Oct. 27.

They sued for refund of the full package price, compensation for loss of holiday enjoyment and some minor damages: the tour operator had been at fault because of failing to warn them from the upcoming hurricane. The tour operator argued the general hazard of hurricanes in the Carribean was a fact of general knowledge and hurricane Wilma had only developed after they had arrived.

Supreme Court upheld the decision of the court of appeal that plantiff was entitled to a partly refund of the package price (except for the first three days) as well as to compensation for loss of holiday enjoyment and further damages. Even though the general hazard of hurricanes in the Carribean indeed was a fact of general knowledge and the development of hurricane Wilam and its track not foreseeable at the time of booking nor at the time of departure, the tour operator should have informed about the duration of the hurricane season when hurricanes are more likely.

Although it was only ascertained that plaintiff had booked for fair weather, Supreme Court concluded that it was likely that he would have booked another destination if properly informed. Even though plaintiff and his fiancé neither would have enjoyed the particular package tour if information had been given they probably would have enjoyed another one of equal shape which therefore also constiuted loss of holiday enjoyment.

Supreme Court again opposed a conceptional formula to detetermine immaterial damages. Courts rather had to assess these damages due to the cicumstances of each individual case.

Judgement 4 Ob 130/09k of Sep. 29, 2009 is not published yet.

Thursday, November 05, 2009

Austrian Supreme Court: compensation for loss of holiday enjoyment does not depend on certain percentage of price reduction granted for malperformance

Contrary to settled jurisdiction of Commercial Court Vienna, Austrian Supreme Court (OGH) in a recently published decision held that compensation for loss of holiday enjoyment would not depend on a certain percentage of price reduction granted for malperformance. Commercial Court Vienna had usually only granted compensation for loss of holiday enjoyment in cases were malperformance of the package tour contract entitled to a price reduction of at least 50 percent. In two previous decisions Supreme Court had not referred to a certain percentage of price reduction but argued that compensation for loss of holiday enjoyment could only be granted if a (not to low) treshold of relevant malperfomance was exceeded.

The new decision now emphasizes the different purposes of compensation for loss of holiday enjoyment on the one hand and price reduction for malperformance on the other hand and favours a position that compensation for loss of holiday enjoyment was only excluded in bagatelle cases. A treshold of entitlement to 50 percent price reduction would limit compensation for loss of holiday enjoyment to cases of massive annoyance which would not be in line with art. 5 of the European Package Travel Directive.

Full text of OGH decision 6 Ob 231/08a of Sep. 18, 2009 available in German here>>.

Friday, August 21, 2009

Austria: no liability for depressive mood following massive flight delay

Plaintiff had booked a package tour to Turkey together with his wife and their two children. Because of technical problems, the outward flight to Turkey was delayed for 26 hrs. Plaintiff claimed that because of a depressive psychosis he was suffering from, the fligth delay had caused a depressive mood which had prevented him from enjoying his holidays. Even his wife had not been able to enjoy the holidays as she had to look after him. Both of them had hardly left the hotel room.

Back home in Austria he sued for compensation for loss of holiday enjoyment and some minor expenses he had had becuase of the flight delay.

Upon defendant's appeal Regional Court (Landesgericht Innsbruck) in judgement 2 R 170/09b of June 19, 2009 for the most part dismissed the claim: plaintiff had not mentioned his disease when booking the package tour and same had not been offered as being specifically suitable for mentally ill persons. The depressive mood therfore could not be regarded an adequate consequence of the flight delay. Plaintiff also had failed to explain why he needed specific care.